Not in our widest imagination would we have thought, but now in a stunning turn of events, the improbable unfolds right before our eyes. Plymouth Argyle have pulled off the unthinkable, defeating Liverpool 1-0 in the FA Cup fourth round tie on Sunday evening. The underdogs, rooted to the foot of the Championship, sent the Reds crashing out of the competition, sparking scenes of unbridled joy at Home Park.
Ryan Hardie’s 53rd-minute penalty proved to be the decisive moment and just enough to wreck havoc, as Arne Slot’s team, weakened by a plethora of changes, struggled to find their rhythm. The spot kick was awarded after Harvey Elliott’s raised arms made contact with the ball, and Hardie made no mistake from 12 yards.
The victory — a quench to Plymouth’s thirst and resolve, as they withstood a late onslaught from Liverpool to secure one of the most famous wins in their history. Miron Muslic, the new Plymouth coach, has infused the team with a renewed sense of vigor and purpose, and this result will undoubtedly be a defining moment in his tenure.
Liverpool, on the other hand, will be left to ponder the consequences of their team selection. Slot’s decision to rest many of his star players, including Mohamed Salah and Cody Gakpo, ultimately proved costly, as the team lacked cohesion and attacking flair.
Despite the introduction of Darwin Nunez from the bench, Liverpool failed to muster a meaningful response, and their hopes of securing an unprecedented quadruple were extinguished. Plymouth, meanwhile, can bask in the glory of their triumph, as they book their place in the fifth round of the FA Cup.
The match itself was a tale of two halves, with Plymouth weathering an early storm before gaining a foothold in the contest. The introduction of Darko Gyabi at halftime injected life into the side, as the midfielder’s physical presence and vision helped to turn the tide in Plymouth’s favor.
As the clock ticked down, the tension mounted, and Plymouth’s players showed extraordinary resolve to see out the victory. Conor Hazard, the Plymouth goalkeeper, made a string of crucial saves in the dying minutes of the match, including a breathtaking stop from Nunez in the 99th minute.
The final whistle sparked scenes of unbridled joy, as Plymouth’s players and fans celebrated a victory that will go down in history. For Liverpool, the defeat will serve as a wake-up call of their non invincible status, as they refocus their attention on the Merseyside derby against Everton on Wednesday evening.
Plymouth’s triumph was built on a solid defensive foundation, with the likes of Maksym Talovierov and Nikola Katic producing outstanding performances to repel Liverpool’s attacks. The victory also paraded the team’s newfound spirit and determination, which has been instilled by Muslic since his arrival.
For Arne Slot’s Liverpool, the defeat raises questions about the team’s strength in depth and their ability to cope with injuries and suspensions. Slot’s decision to rest key players backfired on the evening, and the team paid the price for their lack of cohesion and disjointed attacking flair.
The match will be remembered for its drama and tension, as well as the heroic performance of Plymouth’s players. For the Reds, it’s back to the drawing board, as they seek to regroup and refocus ahead of their next challenge.